Applied security capability
Awareness

Understands why security must support business needs and the importance of being able to demonstrate that relationship
Aware of some key, well-understood, security principles and can demonstrate an awareness of some Cyber Security relevant technologies
Understands why it is important to gain confidence in security measures and can describe some straightforward mechanisms such as pen-tests
Understands and can describe basic security concepts
Working

Aware of the need to provide traceability between business need and security requirements.
Gathers and derives simple or obvious security requirements for highly standardised use cases, using well-established guidance that is unlikely to be contentious
Provides basic security advice to address standard security needs. Advice could be written or verbal. Knows the limitations and scope for what advice can be given and when to draw on others’ expertise
Is aware of and follows appropriate process such as quality control arrangements
Understands and can apply a range of basic approaches to assurance and understands their applicability
Meaningfully describes straightforward security concepts and their business applicability
Ensures security recommendations and risk statements developed are reasonably and well contextualised to the business need under consideration
Practitioner

Elicits security requirements based on straightforward approaches such as threat/vulnerability/impact analysis. Security needs will include an understanding of the user as part of the overall system
Helps organisations to derive and reason about their security needs, such as understanding and applying security principles to particular business scenarios
Interprets and clarifies management or organisational intention with regards to security, such as described in risk appetite statements. This includes interpreting such statements into meaningful and appropriate security requirements
Provides security advice to non-standard use cases, drawing on and using experts in specific topics or technologies
Uses standardised control frameworks (such as 27001/2) appropriately, with awareness of their strengths and limitations
Understands when security measures might impact on users or business needs and provides effective advice to help the business make an appropriate decision
Applies a range of assurance approaches, with a clear understanding of the strengths and limitations of each approach. There is a clear ability to map the assurance options recommended directly to the security need to be addressed
Assurance and confidence is not limited to a point in time, but seeks to address confidence across the system/service life cycle
Provides meaningful security and risk communication in a range of scenarios.
Understands and takes account of the limitations of various risk communication mechanisms such qualitative v quantitative approaches
Expert

Considers complicated, non-obvious security needs, e.g. where the connections between business need, the technology that supports that need and how it might be impacted are important to work out
Works closely with those who ‘own’ business needs, deduces their tolerances with regard to things they care about and turns those into meaningful security statements that can be applied. This might be either complicated and specific, or simple scenarios with broad applicability
Delivers security advice that is contextualised and appropriate for the strategic customer need
Avoids providing ‘point’ solutions or advice that does not address the overall key need. Looks at the wider ‘system’ including sociotechnical considerations (e.g. the role the user plays in meeting the desired security outcomes)
Provides security advice that extends beyond particular technologies of which the candidate is familiar and draws upon and directs appropriate expertise to solve the bigger security problem. Ensures the overall technical coherence and quality of advice
Together with assurance experts, develops and applies novel approaches to assurance of products/systems/services
Understands and applies different approaches to product, implementation and operational assurance. Uses each appropriately to derive a genuine understanding of confidence that the overall business objective is protected
Provides technical leadership for specific experts (be they pen-testers, product or behavioural assurance, for example) in the context of a specific technical assurance or confidence challenge
Effectively communicates difficult risk and security concepts in accessible ways that can be clearly understood by business leaders. Contributes to and develops risk communication strategies